This is our sixth year taking a moment during the IndyCar offseason to revisit some careers from notable names to compete in the history of American open-wheel racing. This year provided a theme that spanned multiple decades and consideration for these great drivers in IndyCar history.
The final part of this series rounds out with another champion celebrating an anniversary. After looking back on the drivers who celebrated 20th and 30th anniversaries for what were their final IndyCar championships, we finish on a driver celebrating the ten-year anniversary of his one-and-only title. Unfortunately, this driver has been sidelined for the last three years after an accident at Mid-Ohio that, though he walked away from as if it was any other accident, left him with concussion-like symptoms that have kept him from the race car.
It is Simon Pagenaud
Where was Pagenaud coming from?
Growing up in France, Pagenaud began karting off the back of his family's supermarket success in his home country. His first foray into car racing was in the Formula Renault system, which was a developing drivers at a staggering rate.
Pagenaud was successful up each step of the ladder system, second in Formula Campus in 2001, third in French Formula Renault in 2002, third in Formula Renault 2000 Masters in 2003 and he was second in the 2004 Formula Renault 2000 Eurocup championship, sandwiched between American Red Bull junior drivers Scott Speed and Colin Fleming. It led to a shot at the Formula Renault 3.5 Series, the top level of the Formula Renault system, and basically a step away from Formula One.
Driving for Saulnier Racing, Pagenaud was at one of the weaker teams in the series. Though he finished in the points of the first four races, his best finish was fourth and he had three top five finishes from 18 races. Pagenaud finished on 30 points, 17th in the championship and between Alx Danielsson (30 points) and Miloš Pavlović (19 points). Pagenaud's teammate Ryo Fukuda only scored 11 points. Meanwhile, Robert Kubica took the title while an Australian named Will Power was seventh in the championship with two victories and four podium finishes.
Off those Formula Renault 3.5 results, Pagenaud turned his eyes to the United States and joined the Derrick Walker-led Team Australia's Formula Atlantics Championship effort with James Davison as his teammate. Competing against the likes of Graham Rahal, Raphael Matos, David Martínez, Jonathan Bomarito and James Hinchcliffe, Pagenaud was an overlooked driver at the start of the season. However, Pagenaud showed remarkable consistency with nine top five finishes from 12 races. He only won once but he had six total poiudm finishes. While Graham Rahal won five times, Rahal had only seven top five finishes and five finishes of 15th or worse, allowing Pagenaud to take the title by 16 points.
With the championship, Pagenaud earned $2 million in funding toward a spot on the 2007 Champ Car grid.
What did IndyCar look like when Pagenaud started in the series?
We did not realize it but we were at the very end of The Split.
Champ Car was coming off a season with 14 races on seven street courses, six road courses and one oval with the series having races on three networks, albeit all time-buy broadcasts though seven races were on network television and the other half were on Speed Channel. In 2007, Champ Car was still on 14 races, but all were on road or street courses, and Champ Car had three cancelled rounds, one of which was supposed to be in Zhuhai, China. Denver was cancelled due to a scheduling conflict with the Democratic National Convention, and a Phoenix street race that was supposed to run December 2 was cancelled due to lack of funding.
The 2007 season did see a Las Vegas street race run on Easter Sunday while Mont-Tremblant hosted American open-wheel racing for the first time in 39 years, and it was one of three consecutive Canadian rounds on the calendar ahead of Toronto and Edmonton. Champ Car made a return to Europe with rounds in Zolder, Belgium and Assen, Netherlands. With the penultimate round at Surfers Paradise, Australia and the season finale in Mexico City, half of the championship was held outside the United States, including the final four rounds. The final American race was Road America on August 12.
The 2007 season was also the introduction of the Panel DP01 chassis with a 2.65-liter turbocharged Cosworth V8. Seventeen cars were on the Champ Car grid representing essentially ten teams.
Meanwhile, the IRL was coming off a 14-race season in 2006, but the schedule grew to 17 races in 2007 as all 14 races returned while Mid-Ohio and Belle Isle were added to the schedule, and the newly opened Iowa Speedway hosted an inaugural event. Between the 31 races held over the 2006 and 2007 seasons, only four had more than 20 cars start a race, and two of those were Indianapolis 500s. No other races touched two-dozen starters.
In 2006, Panoz chassis were still in use but Chip Ganassi Racing used the Panoz only on road courses, as did Scott Sharp at Fernández Racing. Rahal Letterman Racing used the Panoz chassis for the first five races before switching to Dallara for the remainder of the season, expect for Sonoma. All cars were using Honda engines, and all cars would remain using Honda engines in 2007 with every chassis for that season being a Dallara chassis as well.
How does IndyCar look now?
We are coming off the 15th season of the current chassis and engine regulations. The Dallara DW12 chassis has been in use since the 2012 season, and the 2.2-liter twin-turbocharged V6 engines have been the main use during that time, though it has somewhat been forgotten that Honda ran a single turbo for the first two seasons of these regulations before adopting the twin ahead of the 2014 season. Chevrolet and Honda have remained the two engine suppliers since the 2013 season.
With IndyCar's new charter system, 25 cars are entered for every race and 105 consecutive races have had at least 24 starters. Ten teams were represented on the grid this past season. Of those ten teams, Dale Coyne Racing is the only one that was competing in the 2007 Champ Car season.
This past season had 18 races held on 17 circuits. Of the 17 circuits, five were ovals, six were street courses and six were road courses. All of the races were held on the North American continent with only one race in Canada, and it was an inaugural event, a street race in Markham, Ontario, about 20 miles north of Toronto. Markham was one of three inaugural events in 2026, all of which were street races. The first was held in Arlington, Texas. The last was on the streets of Washington, D.C.
What did Pagenaud do in-between?
As a rookie with Team Australia, Pagenaud maintained consistent at a higher level. Though he lost an engine in the season opener in Las Vegas and had a minor accident at Long Beach, Pagenaud went on to have seven consecutive top ten finishes after that with five top five races in that span. He was sixth in the championship at that point before finishing eighth in the final standings, the top rookie.
After that rookie season, Pagenaud was left without a seat as reunification occurred. Pagenaud was likely going to be leaving Team Australia for the 2008 season, and he tested for Conquest Racing alongside Franck Perera at Sebring over February 2-4. On February 22, Champ Car and the Indy Racing League announced a merger effective immediately for the 2008 season.
With no seat available for the reunited IndyCar season, Pagenaud received an opportunity with Acura's LMP2 program and Gil de Ferran's newly formed de Ferran Motorsports. The team debuted at the fourth round at Miller Motorsports Park, where they were third in class. De Ferran Motorsports had two more class podiums, a third at Belle Isle and second at Laguna Seca to close the season.
Pagenaud spent four years in sports cars, splitting between Acura's American Le Mans Series efforts and Peugeot's LMP1 program. In ALMS, Pagenaud and de Ferran were runners-up in the 2009 LMP1 championship despite winning five of ten races. In 2010, Pagenaud moved to Highcroft Racing where he and David Brabham took the LMP title. At Peugeot, won three times in the Le Mans Series, and he twice started at the 24 Hours of Le Mans for the factory effort, finishing second overall in 2011 with Sébastien Bourdais and Pedro Lamy.
However, the IndyCar itch was still there, and with ties to Honda through the Acura prototype program Pagenaud was still a highly coveted driver. In 2011, as Acura pulled out of the ALMS after the 12 Hours of Sebring, Pagenaud became a super-sub in IndyCar. At Barber Motorsports Park, he replaced Ana Beatriz, who broke both wrists in the St. Petersburg opener. Pagenaud was eighth in his first single-seater race in well over three years. Pagenaud jumped in for Justin Wilson after Wilson suffered a broken vertebra in Mid-Ohio practice, and Pagenaud drove for Simona de Silvestro at Sonoma after de Silverstro had visa issues re-entering the country.
The ball was well in motion for Pagenaud to return to IndyCar full-time in 2012. Confirmed to drive for Schmidt-Hamilton Motorsports, Pagenaud did not take long to score good results. He opened with finishes of sixth, fifth and second. He added there more podium finishes and finished fifth in the championship. Due to his lack of oval experience, Pagenaud was classified as a rookie and to this date remains the only driver in IndyCar history to win rookie of the year twice.
Pagenaud spent two more seasons at Schmidt-Hamilton Motorsports, which would later become Schmidt Peterson Motorsports. His first career victory came in the second race of the Belle Isle doubleheader in 2013. A strong end to the season, which included another victory at Baltimore, lifted Pagenaud to third in the championship.
With four consecutive top five finishes, including a victory in the Grand Prix of Indianapolis, Pagenaud looked to be a championship challenger in 2014. A second victory came in Houston. He did enough to remain mathematically alive for the title entering the Fontana finale, but he was quite a distance off Will Power and Hélio Castroneves. Due to double points and an mechanical issue, Pagenaud was dropped to fifth in the final championship standings.
Those three years at Schmidt-Hamilton-Peterson Motorsports were enough for Pagenaud to catch the eye of Roger Penske and earn a spot in a four-car lineup at Team Penske for 2015. However, it was a challenging change. Through the first ten races, Pagenaud had one podium finishes and five results outside the top ten. He had two podium finishes all season and ended up 11th in the championship while his teammates were all in the championship top five.
With the pressure on, Pagenaud came out in 2016 with a pair of runner-up finishes to open the season. He followed that with three consecutive victories. Pagenaud had a firm control on the championship even as teammate Will Power put up a strong fight. The title went to the final race, but Pagenaud left no question who the best driver was, winning the Sonoma finale from pole position to emphatically take the championship.
Pagenaud remained a force in 2017, but he had a new challenger within the team in Josef Newgarden. Though Pagenaud had 13 top five finishes, Newgarden took the title thanks to four victories to Pagenaud's two. Newgarden had nine podium finishes while Pagenaud had six. After a tough 2018 season where Pagenaud was sixth in the championship but had no victories and only four top five finishes, everyone was looking at 2019 as Pagenaud's final season with Penske. With no top five finishes in the first four races, it felt inevitable he would be replaced.
Then came the rain. A shower late in the Grand Prix of Indianapolis brought Pagenaud to life. He chased down Scott Dixon to take the lead with two laps remaining and Pagenaud took his first victory in over a year-and-a-half. The following week, Pagenaud won pole position for the Indianapolis 500. In the race, Pagenaud was the best car, but had Alexander Rossi on his heels for much of the race, and it appeared Rossi would have better fuel mileage and pace in the final stint. Rossi took the lead, but a late caution allowed Pagenaud to push at the end. With two laps to go, Pagenaud took the lead for good and was able to hold off Rossi to win the Indianapolis 500.
That was enough for Penske to keep Pagenaud around. He was second in the 2019 championship, but in those two additional seasons afterward, Pagenaud only won once, and he was eighth in the championship each year. After seven seasons, Pagenaud was released from Penske and left for a reunion with Honda at Meyer Shank Racing.
The partnership began promising. Through the first ten races, Pagenaud had seven top ten finishes and was second at the Grand Prix of Indianapolis. He was tenth in the championship after those ten races. Over the final seven races, his best finish was ninth and he had an average finish of 20th. The 2023 season started out worse. Through the first six races, his best finish was 17th. After finishes of 13th and 14th respectively at Detroit and Road America, things were picking up.
In practice for the Mid-Ohio round, Pagenaud spun entering turn four and barreled rolled in the runoff area. Despite the look of the accident, Pagenaud walked away under his own power but he was not clear due to a concussion. The lingering effects of the accident kept Pagenaud out of the car for the remainder of the 2023 season, and he was replaced at Meyer Shank Racing after the 2023 season.
Pagenaud has not raced since the accident, but he did join Cadillac Formula One Team as a simulator driver at the end of last year.
What impression did Pagenaud leave on IndyCar?
What always stood out to me about Pagenaud was his consistency and his ability to bring a car home in one piece.
In 207 starts, Pagenaud was running at the finish of 192 of them. That is 15 retirements in a 14-season career. For comparison, when they were Team Penske teammates from 2015 to 2021, Will Power had 19 retirements during that span. Josef Newgarden has had 12 retirements over the last six seasons alone.
If you looked just at 2012 through 2021, Pagenaud had ten retirements, just as many as Alexander Rossi, who debuted in 2016, but fewer than Colton Herta (whose rookie season was in 2019 and Herta had 12 in three seasons). Other notable drivers with more retirements in that ten-season span were Scott Dixon (17), Ed Carpenter (19), Marco Andretti (19), Charlie Kimball (20), Tony Kanaan (22), Josef Newgarden (24), Graham Rahal (25) and Power (25). In those ten seasons, Takuma Sato had the most with 47 and Ryan Hunter-Reay was second-most with 32.
These are Pagenaud's contemporaries, past champions and Indianapolis 500 winners. Even Carpenter, Andretti and Kimball were race winners. Andretti was in the championship top five with Pagenaud in 2013. Pagenaud just had a way of staying out of trouble and being quick in the process.
If you boiled it down to just lead lap finishes over those ten seasons, Pagenaud is second on 137 behind only Dixon, who had 139 lead lap finishes over those ten seasons, 165 total races. Third was Newgarden on 118 ahead of Power (115), Rahal (112), Hunter-Reay (111) and Andretti (91). For percentages, Rossi had lead lap finishes in 73.195% of his starts in that ten-year period, though he only joined the grid in 2016. Pagenaud's lead lap finish rate was 83.030% in that span. Herta's lead lap finish rate over that period was 72.91667%.
Over his entire career, Pagenaud finished on the lead lap 79.71% percent of the time. Álex Palou is currently finishing on the lead lap in exactly 75% of his starts (87/116). Patricio O'Ward is slightly better at 76.612%. Christian Lundgaard is slightly off that at 73.563%. Kyle Kirkwood is at 67.441%. David Malukas' rate is 59.493%.
Of the 25 drivers who ran full-time in 2026, none are better than Pagenaud at the moment. Dixon still had the best rate among active drivers at 76.43%, but for Dixon to reach Pagenaud's rate, he would need to finish 71 consecutive races on the lead lap. That would be just over four consecutive seasons without finishing a lap down. That is essentially running into April 2032. That isn't going to happen.
I think we are going to remember how Pagenaud left IndyCar because it didn't feel like the end. His Mid-Ohio accident was stunning but he walked away. He waved to the crowd and everything. There was a thought he could have continued that weekend. Even when it came out he had a concussion, there was a thought he would be back for Toronto in two weeks or at some point that season. No one in the immediate aftermath of that accident thought that would be the final time we would see Pagenaud race anywhere let alone in an IndyCar. Yet it remains the final time anyone saw him competing.
A comeback doesn't feel like it is on the table. Not that it is impossible, but it is not something we know is being worked on. We know Pagenaud is still active in motorsports and IndyCar. He supported Scott McLaughlin for a period at Team Penske and guided McLaughlin to pole position for the Indianapolis 500 in 2024. Pagenaud was assisting Théo Pourchaire when Pourchaire was briefly in IndyCar and looking to make a career in the United States. As stated above, Pagenaud is a simulator driver for Cadillac's Formula One program. This accident has not prevent him from being involved.
Being in a simulator is an encouraging sign. Pagenaud can handle some of the stimulus of a race car, but the simulator has its differences from the real thing. There are number of things he is not facing behind the wheel of a computer screen. He doesn't get shaken like a martini if he flips in the simulator.
We have seen a number of drivers comeback after years away after severe accidents. Davey Hamilton came back six years after suffering leg injuries. Kenny Bräck returned after being broken in half. Dario Franchitti returned to driving this year racing this year in the Dubai 24 Hour, and Franchitti was on the reserve list for the 24 Hours of Le Mans. Robert Wickens has not let paralysis prevent him from getting into a race car. There is hope for Pagenaud, but concussions and brain injuries are taken much more seriously today than 20 years ago. There is a greater awareness of what 100% doesn't feel like and when is not the right moment to get back in a race car. Pagenaud is only going to return when he feels ready. We don't know when that will be or if he will ever feel ready again.
Looking beyond the accident, we saw a rather flawless driver for over a decade in IndyCar, and that was despite missing four seasons due to reunification leaving Pagenaud without a seat. He accomplished everything you could ask for in an IndyCar career; a championship, an Indianapolis 500 victory, we saw all of Simon Pagenaud, and should be grateful we got to see it.